Our Favorite Baking Sheets for the Oven and Beyond

Best Overall Baking Sheet

Price at Amazon: $21.99 for 2

The Nordic Ware Naturals Baker's Half Sheet has secured the top spot in the hearts of many home cooks. Made of pure aluminum, it guarantees a lifetime of durability without rusting. Whether you're baking sweets or savory dishes, from cookies to sheet pan dinners, this is the go-to pan.

With its 20-gauge bare aluminum, it efficiently conducts heat, ensuring even and quick cooking. Its rolled edges make it fairly warp-resistant, even at high heats and sudden temperature changes.

Best Professional Baking Sheet

Price at Amazon: $16.69

Price at Wayfair: $16.69

If you can't locate the Nordic Ware pan or find the stamped logo cleaning bothersome, consider the Artisan Professional Classic Aluminum Half Sheet as a dependable alternative. Crafted from sturdy, uncoated 18-gauge aluminum, it can withstand high heat.

This baking pan ensures even heating from the center to the edges, delivering consistent baking results. Ideal for sheet cakes, roasted veggies, cookies, and more, this half-size pan is a reliable workhorse in the kitchen for bake sales, parties, gatherings, and everyday meals.

Best Design Baking Sheet

Price at Sur La Table: $27.99

Price at Great Jones: $40

Meet Holy Sheet, the kitchen superhero in half-size! With its bold and colorful appearance, this pan boasts a custom nonstick ceramic coating, ensuring a quick, easy, and drama-free cleanup. Unlike many other baking sheets, Holy Sheet can go straight into the dishwasher, making your life even easier.

The smaller size is perfect for saving space in kitchens. What truly sets Holy Sheet apart is its beautiful collection of vibrant color options – it comes in five joyful, electric colors that add a touch of fun to your cooking experience.

Best Baking Sheet Set

Price at Amazon: $26.98

For those seeking versatility in sizes, the Nordic Ware three-piece set is the top choice. It includes a Quarter Sheet, Jelly Roll, and Half Sheet Pan for the ultimate baking set. Crafted from pure aluminum, these pans offer superior heat conductivity, ensuring consistently and evenly browned baked goods every time.

With a lifetime durability and rust-free guarantee, these premium pans are built to last. The encapsulated galvanized steel rims add an extra layer of durability, preventing warping and maintaining the integrity of your baking sheets.

Best Nonstick Baking Sheet

Price at Amazon: $25.95

Oxo stands out as a reliable brand for kitchen essentials, and their nonstick sheet pan is no exception. This sturdy and nonstick pan ensures even baking for sweets, thanks to its aluminized steel construction (in contrast to pure aluminum).

The precision-engineered curved, tapered design allows access to hard-to-reach spots, while the square-rolled edge is tall enough to accommodate shallow sheet cakes or items that require a bit more containment than a standard sheet pan provides.

Best Nonstick Baking Sheet Set

Price at Amazon: $24.99 for 2

The Circulon Total Bakeware Nonstick Cookie Sheet truly lives up to its name, ensuring that no food adheres to its surface. With a heavy-gauge steel construction, it guarantees uniform heat distribution, and the warp-resistant rolled edges enhance its overall strength.

The premium, metal utensil safe nonstick coating on raised circles promotes superior food release and facilitates effortless cleanup.

Oven-safe up to 450 degrees Fahrenheit, the cookie pans feature wide handles for a generous and confident grip. Moreover, the hassle-free cleaning process eliminates the need for any scrubbing.

Best Three-Sided Baking Sheet

Price at King Arthur: $22.95

The King Arthur baking sheet stands out as the only model on this list with three sides, allowing for the convenient sliding of roasted vegetables or scones onto a platter in one swift motion.

This unique design also facilitates easier access to the rimmed edges, allowing a spatula to go straight in, particularly handy when dealing with sticky food that requires some gentle jabs to loosen. The tray exudes a remarkable sturdiness while remaining lightweight, and it maintains its integrity without warping or discoloration even after years of extensive use.

Best Baking Sheet For Cookie

Price at Amazon: $32.60

Many prefer rimmed sheets for their versatility, but if you lean towards a rimless cookie sheet, we recommend the Vollrath Wear-Ever Aluminum Cookie Sheet. This two-handled pan is easy to rotate in the oven, ensuring even baking for cookies, and it is also easy to clean.

Made with 10-gauge aluminum, its thickness is crucial to prevent warping without the support of rims. However, it may not be as versatile as our other recommendations, lacking the containment for roasting vegetables or capturing juices from a sheet-pan dinner.

Best Nonstick Large Baking Sheet

Price at Amazon: $55

Price at Caraway: $55

If your baking sheets serve multiple purposes or if you appreciate the combination of aesthetics and functionality, consider splurging on Caraway's ceramic-coated, aluminized-steel large baking sheet.

With robust stainless-steel handles and an array of beautiful color options, it not only looks appealing but also functions exceptionally well as a baking sheet with a high temperature tolerance—oven-safe up to 550ºF.

After baking, maintaining its pristine condition is a breeze; simply hand wash the sheets and return them to their organizers for storage.

Best Baking Sheet For Baking

Price at Amazon: $49.95

One might assume that any baking sheet is universally suitable for all baking purposes, but it's not that straightforward. In reality, jelly roll pans prove to be more adept at baking than the average sheet pan.

Specifically designed for jelly roll cakes, they are versatile enough for thin sheet cakes, blondies, cookies, brownies, and smaller servings of roasted recipes.

All-Clad's nonstick jelly roll pan provides ample opportunities for various baking needs, featuring convenient angled edges that ensure your oven mitts won't come into contact with your food while moving in and out of the oven.

Best Nonstick Quarter Baking Sheet

Price at Great Jones: $50 for 2

Great Jones also offers quarter-sheets, available in a set of two. Constructed similarly to the half-sheet, they are equally effective for all your roasting, broiling, and baking needs. These quarter-sheets can also double as platters, much like their larger counterpart, the Holy Sheet.

With vibrant color options such as royal blue, raspberry red, and forest green, they add a touch of style to your table. Whether filled with appetizers like crudites and dips or serving as a platform for cheese and crackers, these quarter-sheets are also suitable for presenting main dishes like roast chicken or whole fish.

Best Baking Sheet For Roasting

Price at Amazon: $29.99

Cheat Sheets’ innovative design simplifies the task of separating foods while maintaining a unified cooking surface, thanks to the inclusion of silicone divider pans that fit neatly into the baking sheet. The metal sheet and silicone pans are oven-safe up to 450 degrees, making the set versatile for various baking and roasting needs.

It's perfect for making an entire oven-baked meal, including dessert, on a single pan, and equally convenient for prepping food ahead while keeping individual components separate.

The ability to remove the individual trays at any time is especially advantageous when dealing with ingredients that require different cooking times.

Best Durable Baking Sheet

Price at Amazon: $27.28 for 2

Price at Wayfair: $27.28 for 2

Chicago Metallic takes pride in presenting Commercial II, an exceptional range of bakeware. This line includes both traditional uncoated and dual-coated, diamond-quality non-stick bakeware, offering the strength and durability needed to achieve delicious results consistently.

Crafted from heavy-weight aluminized steel, the Commercial II line ensures superior heat conduction and even baking outcomes. The Lifetime warranty guarantees avid bakers a robust construction and long-lasting product. While this collection is dishwasher safe, hand-washing is recommended to prolong the product's life.

Best High End Baking Sheet

Price at Amazon: $199.95

The Hestan OvenBond ovenware set showcases a triple-bonded, 18/10 stainless steel construction with an aluminum core, ensuring superior and even heat conductivity. This set features a brushed stainless steel baking surface and a polished exterior, providing a sleek and modern look for any kitchen.

The half-sheet pan included in this set adheres to the standard size for cookies, buns, and more, and its sturdy handles facilitate easy maneuvering of baked goods in and out of the oven. For those not in need of the complete set, individual pieces are available for purchase.

Best-Extra Large Baking Sheet

Price at Amazon: $21.99

Larger than a typical half-sheet pan yet still compatible with home ovens, this 21 x 15-inch baking sheet provides additional space for baking biscuits, cookies, and pastries.

Ideal for crafting extra-long loaves of bread that may not fit on a standard sheet, it is constructed from steel with a dark finish, retaining heat effectively to prevent cookies from spreading too rapidly.

The nonstick coating ensures easy release of cookies and other baked goods, facilitating a simpler cleanup process. Although dishwasher safe, its substantial size may pose a challenge to fit into most dishwashers.